The Senior People You Want To Hire May Never See Your Job Advert

When a senior role opens up, the instinct is to write a good advert, post it on the usual sites, and wait for the right person to turn up. For junior and mid-level roles that can work very well, especially considering Wallace Hind’s advertising network. But for senior hires that really matter to your business, success often has far less to do with the advert itself than how effectively the role is taken to market.

The best people are not looking

A strong Operations Director, Head of Engineering or Sales Director is usually in a job they do well, for an employer who values them. They are not scrolling through vacancies on job boards or social media on a Sunday evening. Most of them are busy delivering for their current business, and the idea of moving only occurs to them when someone they respect raises it.

An advert reaches whoever happens to be looking, which includes some excellent people but also a lot of people who are looking for reasons you would want to understand, prior to hire. Some have been made redundant, some are unhappy where they are, and some are actively exploring multiple opportunities. It is a bit like putting a sign in your shop window and hoping your ideal customer happens to walk past at exactly the right time.

Why senior candidates will not apply anyway

Even when a strong candidate does see your advert, there is a good chance they will ignore it. Applying for a senior role carries real risk. Their details go into a system they do not control, the advert may be visible to their own employer or competitors, and rumours that they are looking can spread faster than anyone would like. People at this level are naturally protective of their reputation, and a public application process often offers little of the discretion they need.

What actually reaches them

Senior people hear about new roles through conversations. Someone that they trust makes a call, describes an opportunity, and gives them space to think about it without commitment. That is the principle behind an executive search, and it is why retained work looks so different from simply advertising a vacancy.

A proper search starts by mapping the market, working out who does the job well at the businesses you would want to learn from, and building a list of people who fit, whether or not they have ever considered a move. Every approach is made discreetly and personally, and the first conversation is about their ambitions rather than your job description. You can see how each stage works in our process.

This matters particularly for engineering and manufacturing businesses, where the pool of people who can genuinely do a specialist senior role is small and most of them know each other. In a market that tight, the person you want has often already been approached, which means timing, credibility and the quality of the approach all matter.

What you can do to help

The recruiter does the approaching, but you play a big part in whether the conversation goes anywhere. Here are the things that make the biggest difference.

First, be clear about what the role needs to achieve in the first year, rather than listing the tasks. A strong candidate wants to know what success looks like, and a vague brief gives them nothing to get excited about 

Second, be ready to sell the role as well as assess people for it. Someone who is content in their current job needs a reason to move, so think honestly about what you can offer in terms of scope, support, culture and progression.

Third, be transparent about salary, benefits and any long-term incentives early in the process.

Finally, move quickly once you have met someone good. People who are not actively looking have no reason to wait for a slow process, and the best ones will not.

Where an advert still has a place

We would not say never advertise. Adverts are perfectly good for roles where plenty of capable people are actively looking and the stakes of any one hire are lower. The point is that for the roles you cannot afford to get wrong, advertising alone only reaches a fraction of the available talent. The strongest candidates are often the ones who were never looking in the first place. 

If you are hiring a senior leader in Northampton or further afield and want an honest view on how to reach the right people, get in touch for an informal chat. You can also see how we have approached this for other employers in our case studies, or call us on 01604 758857 or email mail@wallacehind.com.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed