Why The Right Recruitment Partner Will Tell You What You Don’t Want To Hear

Most people choose a recruiter the way they choose a restaurant, by how good the experience sounds beforehand.

If a recruiter is enthusiastic, agrees with your brief, tells you the market is full of suitable candidates and promises a shortlist in a couple of weeks. It is a pleasant conversation, and it is often the worst possible sign.

A good and trusted recruitment partner will sometimes say things you would rather not hear. They are doing it because it is the most useful thing they can offer you, and it is worth understanding why.

Why so many recruiters say yes

Saying yes is easy, and it keeps you happy. If a recruiter is paid only when someone is placed, they have every reason to take the role on, agree with your expectations and keep the conversation friendly. Telling you the salary is too low, or that the brief describes someone who does not exist, risks losing the instruction altogether.

The result is a search that starts with a comfortable conversation and then drifts. Candidates turn down the salary, the shortlist is meagre, and three months later the same recruiter is explaining that the market is difficult. The honest conversation still happens, just at the point where it costs you the most.

What an honest conversation sounds like

An honest conversation rarely starts with criticism. It usually starts with a question about something you have taken for granted, and then an honest answer.

The most common points for discussion are:

  • The salary is below what the market pays for this role. Candidates will tell a recruiter exactly why they declined, so a good partner already knows what people at this level are being offered elsewhere, and will say so before you have wasted a month finding out.
  • The brief describes more than one person – many senior job descriptions ask for the strategic thinking of a director, the hands-on skills of a specialist and the salary expectations of someone three levels down. A good recruitment partner will tell you which parts matter most and which you could train or hire around.
  • The role is not as attractive as you think. You know your business well, so it is hard to see it the way an outsider does. A good recruitment partner can tell you what a candidate will think about the location, the scope, the reporting line or the pace of decisions, and help you fix it before you start approaching people.
  • Your own internal processes are the problem – slow feedback, too many interview rounds and long gaps between conversations lose good candidates, and the people who suffer most from it are the ones who are not desperate for a move.
  • The candidate you like is not the right one – this is the hardest of all. A good recruitment partner will tell you honestly if the person you have fallen for is the wrong fit, even when it means the search goes on for a few more weeks.

The Surveyor Analogy

When you buy a house, you want the surveyor who tells you about the damp, the roof and the dodgy extension, not the one who says it all looks lovely. The devastation comes later when the bill arrives for everything it missed.

A recruitment partner is doing a similar job. Their value comes from seeing the problems before you commit money and time to them, which means the conversations that feel awkward are the ones you are really paying for.

Why fees change the conversation

The way a recruiter is paid shapes what they are willing to say. When the fee is a percentage of the salary, there is a quiet incentive to push for a higher salary or to agree with whatever keeps the instruction alive.

A fixed fee agreed at the start removes both.

Our fee does not move with the salary of the person you hire, and we are committed to your search from the first day, so the only thing we are paid to do is get the right person for the role. That makes it much easier to be straight with you. You can see how this works in practice in our process.

Why it matters more in specialist hiring

In engineering and manufacturing, the talent pool for a senior role is small and everyone talks. A badly judged approach, or a role that has been advertised for months can do real damage to how your business is seen. An honest partner will tell you early if the market is thinner than you had hoped, because the right answer might be to widen the search, change the role or look at the problem differently. This is a particular strength of true executive search, where the relationship is built on trust rather than volume.

How to tell if your partner is being straight with you

Four questions and the answers they give will tell you quickly.

  • Have they ever turned down a search or told a client the role was not ready to go to market?
  • Can they tell you what the market is paying for this role, and where your offer sits against it?
  • Will they challenge the brief, or just accept it?
  • When did they last disagreed with a client, what happened?

If every answer is smooth and agreeable, be a little careful. The recruitment partner worth keeping will have a story about a time they said something unwelcome and the client was glad they did. 

What to do when you hear it

Hard feedback is easier to use if you treat it as information rather than criticism. Ask for the evidence behind it, such as what candidates said or what comparable roles are paying. Then decide what you can change and what you cannot, and tell your recruitment partner. A search that adapts after an honest conversation in week one will nearly always beat one that carries on unchanged until week twelve.

At Wallace Hind, being honest with clients matters more to us than keeping every conversation comfortable. We have been working this way with employers across the UK and beyond since 1992, and you can see the results in our case studies. If you would like an honest view on a role you are planning to fill, get in touch for an informal chat. Call us on 01604 758857 or email mail@wallacehind.com.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.
You need to agree with the terms to proceed